As a Catholic order’s building is reduced to rubble, Hà Nội officials urged a visiting U.S. religious freedom panel to stop making assessments “lacking objectivity.”
The Latest: On the afternoon of Nov. 18, the Government Committee for Religious Affairs asked the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) to “consult and exchange views directly” with the authorities before making assessments.
- The stated goal was to “avoid assessments lacking objectivity that affect understanding, trust, and cooperation between the two countries.”
The Details: Nguyễn Tiến Trọng, deputy head of the Government Committee for Religious Affairs under the Ministry of Ethnic and Religious Affairs, made the request at a meeting with a USCIRF delegation led by Vice Chair Cecilia Diane Noland-Heil.
- Commissioner David Andre Anderson and representatives of the U.S. Embassy in Hà Nội also attended.
- For her part, Noland-Heil raised “five issues” that continue to concern the commission, though state media did not specify what they were.
State media coverage of the meeting made no mention of Huế, the L’Accueil site, or the Redemptorists, leaving it unclear whether the USCIRF delegation raised the demolition.
Contacting USCIRF: At 10 a.m. on Nov. 19, Luật Khoa Magazine emailed USCIRF’s press address with three questions:
- What were the five issues that Noland-Heil raised at the meeting?
- Did the delegation raise the L’Accueil demolition with the Vietnamese side?
- How does USCIRF respond to the committee’s request to “avoid assessments lacking objectivity”?
As of 4 p.m. on Nov. 19, Luật Khoa had not received a reply.
The Background: On the night of Sept. 1, 2025, authorities fenced off the L’Accueil site.
Then, On Oct. 24, 2026, the Redemptorists filed a complaint and were told that it had no basis for consideration.
On Nov. 17, Huế city authorities began demolishing the building on the L’Accueil site at 87 Nguyễn Huệ Street, as Luật Khoa Magazine reported.
- According to the Redemptorists, the demolition continued through the night.
By the morning of Nov. 19, the Redemptorists stated that the building had been leveled.
- The site remains fenced off, and the public is barred from entering.
In response to the demolition, the chapter of the Redemptorists’ Vietnamese province issued a statement of protest demanding that authorities make public the legal basis for the demolition.
- “Justice cannot be established by force,” the statement said.
Following the demolition, Huế police cited Resolution 23/2003 to reject the order’s demand to return the land, though they did not specify under which document the state took over the site.
From the USCIRF: The Việt Nam chapter of USCIRF’s 2026 annual report had already named the L’Accueil site, describing the land as “expropriated.” The report also cited two other cases involving religious properties:
- In January 2025, authorities in Đà Nẵng demolished a building belonging to An Hòa Parish.
- In June 2025, authorities in Hồ Chí Minh City demolished a building belonging to the Daughters of Charity.
Based on these findings, USCIRF recommended that the State Department designate Việt Nam a “Country of Particular Concern” (CPC).
- In March, Foreign Ministry spokesperson Phạm Thu Hằng said that the USCIRF report was “based on evidence with malicious intent aimed at Việt Nam.”
USCIRF and Việt Nam: The USCIRF is an independent, bipartisan advisory body created by the U.S. Congress that recommends each year which countries are severe violators of religious freedom.
- The State Department then decides whether to designate a country a “Country of Particular Concern” (CPC).
The U.S. previously designated Việt Nam a CPC from September 2004 to November 2006.
- In May 2005, the two countries signed a binding agreement in which Việt Nam committed to enforcing a new law on religion, ending forced renunciations of faith, and allowing churches to register.
- In return, the U.S. did not impose sanctions.
- According to USCIRF, it was the only time the U.S. has used this kind of agreement.
Since 2022, the State Department has placed Việt Nam on its Special Watch List, a step below CPC.
- The Special Watch List is reissued every year.
- According to USCIRF’s 2026 annual report, Việt Nam was most recently placed on the list on Dec. 29, 2023.
Why It Matters: Under Section 405 of the International Religious Freedom Act of 1998, a CPC designation can trigger a range of U.S. measures, from diplomatic protests and canceled exchanges to aid cuts and limits on exports and credit.
- However, the U.S. can also waive those measures and instead sign a binding agreement requiring the designated country to improve religious freedom rather than face sanctions.
Hoàng Long wrote this news article in Vietnamese and published it in Luật Khoa Magazine on Nov. 19, 2026. The Vietnamese Magazine translated it into English.



Join the conversation