Residents may not understand the complex provisions of the Land Law, but they know exactly what projects are worth sacrificing their land and personal interests for.
For more than a month, the fear of losing homes has hung over the villages at the foot of Ba Vì Mountain and the crowded neighborhoods of Vĩnh Hưng Ward in Hà Nội. Despite the distance between these two locations, residents in both areas share anxiety and anger over the projects that Sun Group plans to construct on their land.
While Ba Vì residents stayed up all night at checkpoints to guard their villages, Vĩnh Hưng residents protested in the streets around the clock. However, a recent decision directly undermined all their efforts. [1] [2]
On the afternoon of Oct. 28, the Hà Nội People’s Council approved adding the Ba Vì Safari project and the Vĩnh Hưng urban renovation, upgrading, and redevelopment project to the list of land acquisitions for “socio-economic development in the national and public interest.” [3]
Is this reason sufficient to force residents to surrender their land against their will? This question extends beyond Sun Group’s two projects; it applies to the countless other developments that have been built, or are currently being built, under similar justifications over the years.
How Residents Define Public Interest
Interviews with those affected by major developments in the capital—such as the Red River (Sông Hồng) Scenic Boulevard project and Sun Group’s urban renovation in Vĩnh Hưng Ward—highlight a certain consensus.
While residents may not understand the complex provisions of the Land Law, they know very well what they would give up their land for and which projects they think are worth sacrificing their interests for. [4] [5]
To these communities, essential infrastructure like power lines, roads, schools, and clinics defines “the national and public interest.”
For such civic necessities, many are ready to agree to land acquisitions, with some even willing to donate their property without compensation. However, they firmly oppose surrendering their land for commercial endeavors like apartment buildings or golf courses.
In Lĩnh Nam Ward, many people strongly feel this sentiment. An elderly temple caretaker in Thúy Lĩnh Ancient Village, who dedicated 11 years of his youth to the army, now stands firmly against the Red River Scenic Boulevard project. He cannot accept the destruction of a village rooted in generations of history just to accommodate urban development.
“I went to fight to defend the fatherland, and now the fatherland is at peace. Yet now they come back and take my village for no reason, and the Constitution doesn’t allow that,” he said. “What kind of country drives people out when everything is peaceful like this? You would just push our ancestors’ graves into the pond. We will never accept that.”
For this veteran, the eviction is not just about a physical house; it means losing his roots, culture, and community. He refuses to leave without a justifiable reason.
“We absolutely will not accept it. Everyone here agrees that we must keep the ancient village. We cannot leave,” he added.
Notably, he does not deny the state’s authority to acquire land for essential public works.
“If it’s a national road or a bridge and it has to go through, then we’d accept it even if it cuts straight through the village,” he said.
His opposition stems from land being handed over to private companies for commercial gain.
“But now it’s private, and then you hand the land over to them. That I don’t agree with,” he said firmly.
This perspective is widespread along the Red River, where residents are willing to donate land for roads but find the current project is not convincing enough to make them abandon their homeland.
In a petition opposing the Red River Scenic Boulevard project, residents demanded the immediate removal of commercial elements, such as golf courses, resorts, and high-end housing. [6]
Similar outrage surrounds Sun Group’s project in Vĩnh Hưng. A local survey indicates that residents strongly oppose the project because their residential land would be seized to build commercial apartments. [7]
Through protest banners and matching shirts worn during marches, they repeatedly declare their refusal to surrender their homes for a private company’s benefit.
A middle-aged woman in Vĩnh Hưng expressed this frustration angrily: “If the project were to build a road, there’d be nothing to say, but they’re taking it to build apartments and villas and then sell them.”
She noted that a road would garner immediate support “because wide roads make it simple and comfortable for people to get around.”
She added: “If it’s for a school or a clinic, people would strongly support it too.” But, she said, “Instead, they’re pushing people into a corner to benefit a company. We have homes now, and now we don’t know where we’ll go. It’s only the people who suffer, the people who lose out.”
While compensation, resettlement, and future livelihoods remain pressing concerns, these accounts highlight a clear distinction between civic and commercial interests. A road or bridge serves everyone; commercial apartments and golf courses serve only buyers and investors. Above all, the official government approval has not convinced these communities that giving up their land is either necessary or justified.
Public Interest Under the Law
Under Clause 3 of Article 54 of the Constitution and Article 79 of the current Land Law, “socio-economic development in the national and public interest” serves as a primary justification for the state to acquire residents’ land. [8] [9]
However, Việt Nam’s land laws did not always operate this way; early iterations of the law did not recognize “economic development” as a valid ground for land acquisition.
Article 23 of the 1992 Constitution permitted the state to “compulsorily purchase” or “requisition” property from individuals and organizations only out of true necessity “for reasons of national defense, security and the national interest,” requiring payment at “market prices.” Notably, it omitted any mention of economic purposes. [10]
Similarly, Article 27 of the 1993 Land Law restricted land acquisition to scenarios deemed truly necessary “for national defense, security, the national interest, and the public interest.” [11]
While this wording remained unchanged through the 1998 and 2001 amendments, [12] [13] Decree 22/1998 classified business projects, industrial parks, export processing zones, tourist areas, and investment projects as serving “the national interest and the public interest.” [14]
In practice, land was already being acquired for economic ventures under the guise of the common good.
A turning point arrived with the 2003 Land Law, which formally introduced “economic development” as a rationale for land acquisition in Clause 1 of Article 38 and in Article 40. This remained separate from acquisitions “for national defense, security, the national interest and the public interest” detailed in Article 39. [15]
Despite the 1992 Constitution remaining unamended at the time, the state used these provisions to seize land for corporate investment projects.
For instance, during the 2004 land acquisition in Văn Giang, Hưng Yên Province, authorities cited “economic development” under Clause 1 of Article 28 of the 2003 Land Law to justify transferring land to the developer of the Ecopark eco-urban area. [16]
The 2013 Constitution officially permitted land acquisition for socio-economic development in the national and public interest under Clause 3 of Article 54. The 2013 Land Law elaborated on this provision, and the current legal framework has expanded it further. [17] Nevertheless, the definition of this ground remains excessively vague and broad.
Compared with the 2013 Land Law, the 2024 Land Law lists 31 specific cases for “socio-economic development” acquisitions—arguably an attempt to limit bureaucratic discretion. However, it fails to clearly define foundational concepts like “socio-economic development,” “national interest,” and “public interest.” [18] [19]
Article 79 describes acquisition reasons in general terms: maximizing land resources, improving efficiency, developing infrastructure, ensuring social welfare, protecting the environment, and preserving cultural heritage.
These vague descriptions are easily co-opted to justify developments that blur the line between public benefit and commercial profit, such as urban renovation and residential projects.
For example, a developer could argue that a new urban area improves infrastructure and raises tax revenue, while simultaneously reaping massive profits from housing sales and inflated land values.
Historically, many commercial ventures have proceeded under the banner of “socio-economic development,” echoing the Văn Giang case. [20] Today, Sun Group’s ongoing projects in Vĩnh Hưng and Ba Vì force residents to once again question where the boundary between public necessity and private interest truly lies.
This issue matters even more as new mechanisms continue to expand the state’s acquisition powers. On Dec. 11, 2025, the National Assembly passed Resolution 254/2025, which added three new scenarios for “socio-economic development” acquisitions.
One of them targets projects that originated as direct negotiations between residents and companies. [21] Under Clause 2 of Article 3, the state can forcefully acquire the remaining land for these projects, provided that agreements already cover over 75% of the area and 75% of the land users, and the negotiation deadline has expired.
The National Assembly also passed a resolution on the same day that established special mechanisms and policies for major developments in Hà Nội. This allows authorities to acquire land for projects in the “national and public interest” beyond the cases listed in the Land Law. [22]
Is It Necessary?
To ensure that land acquisition remains within its proper scope and serves a public purpose, the state must prove a project is truly necessary, rather than merely pointing to potential economic benefits. Such projects should also undergo impact assessments, public consultation, and independent oversight.
In Britain, authorities seeking to acquire land must present a compelling case that the acquisition serves the public interest and explore alternative options to meet their development goals. [23] Furthermore, they are required to weigh the interests of residents and attempt to reach a reasonable purchase agreement.
Similarly, in the United States, economic development projects promising revenue, jobs, and infrastructure face fierce challenges if they merely transfer property from vulnerable residents to private investors. In such cases, authorities are often forced to modify or halt the project entirely. [24]
In Việt Nam, the current land law does stipulate that land recovery must be “truly necessary.” However, there is no independent body to verify this necessity. When residents along the Red River, in Vĩnh Hưng, or in Ba Vì are eventually forced off the land they have inhabited for years, they may never understand why they had to sacrifice everything for a project that was unprovenly essential.
Thực Sơ wrote this article in Vietnamese and published it in Luật Khoa Magazine on Nov. 12, 2026. The Vietnamese Magazine translated it into English.
- Thành Phương, “Dự án safari Ba Vì: Dân nhiều đêm thức trắng giữ làng vì lo doanh nghiệp ‘cúng trộm’” [Ba Vì safari project: Residents stay up night after night guarding their village for fear the company will “sneak in a ritual”], Luật Khoa tạp chí, September 30, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/09/du-an-safari-ba-vi-dan-nhieu-dem-thuc-trang-giu-lang-vi-lo-doanh-nghiep-cung-trom/.
- Lê Sáng, “Phường Vĩnh Hưng: Hàng trăm người tụ tập liên tiếp nhiều ngày, phản đối dự án của Sun Group” [Vĩnh Hưng Ward: Hundreds gather for days in a row to protest Sun Group’s project], Luật Khoa tạp chí, October 11, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/10/phuong-vinh-hung-hang-tram-nguoi-tu-tap-lien-tiep-nhieu-ngay-phan-doi-du-an-cua-sun-group/.
- Thành Phương, “Hà Nội đưa Safari Ba Vì và Vĩnh Hưng vào diện thu hồi đất ‘vì lợi ích quốc gia, công cộng’” [Hà Nội puts Ba Vì Safari and Vĩnh Hưng on land acquisition list “in the national and public interest”], Luật Khoa tạp chí, October 30, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/10/ha-noi-dua-safari-ba-vi-va-vinh-hung-vao-dien-thu-hoi-dat-vi-loi-ich-quoc-gia-cong-cong/.
- M. Anh, “Quy hoạch trục đại lộ sông Hồng: Những khu vực nào phải di dời và 3 phương án tái định cư mới nhất là gì?” [Sông Hồng boulevard plan: Which areas must relocate, and what are the three latest resettlement options?], Người Quan Sát, May 9, 2026, https://nguoiquansat.vn/quy-hoach-truc-dai-lo-song-hong-nhung-khu-vuc-nao-phai-di-doi-va-3-phuong-an-tai-dinh-cu-moi-nhat-la-gi-290760.html.
- Thảo Phương, “Sun Group làm dự án 186.000 tỷ đồng tại Vĩnh Hưng” [Sun Group takes on 186 trillion đồng project in Vĩnh Hưng], Thương hiệu và Công luận, October 9, 2026, https://hangthat.thuonghieucongluan.com.vn/sun-group-lam-du-an-186-000-ty-dong-tai-vinh-hung-a294546.html.
- Lê Sáng, “Người dân vùng bãi sông Hồng: Yêu cầu bồi thường đúng giá thị trường” [Sông Hồng floodplain residents demand compensation at market prices], Luật Khoa tạp chí, May 18, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/05/nguoi-dan-vung-bai-song-hong-yeu-cau-boi-thuong-dung-gia-thi-truong/.
- Lê Sáng, “‘Tôi sẵn sàng hiến đất mở đường, còn xây chung cư thương mại thì không’ – dân Vĩnh Hưng bức xúc về dự án của Sun Group” [“I’m ready to donate land for a road, but not for commercial apartments”: Vĩnh Hưng residents angry over Sun Group’s project], Luật Khoa tạp chí, October 12, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/10/toi-san-sang-hien-dat-mo-duong-con-xay-chung-cu-thuong-mai-thi-khong-dan-vinh-hung-buc-xuc-ve-du-an-cua-sun-group/.
- “Văn bản hợp nhất 52/VBHN-VPQH năm 2025 Hiến pháp nước Cộng hòa xã hội chủ nghĩa Việt Nam” [Consolidated text 52/VBHN-VPQH of 2025: Constitution of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, n.d., https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bo-may-hanh-chinh/Van-ban-hop-nhat-52-VBHN-VPQH-2025-Hien-phap-nuoc-Cong-hoa-xa-hoi-chu-nghia-Viet-Nam-665872.aspx.
- “Văn bản hợp nhất 44/VBHN-VPQH năm 2026 hợp nhất Luật Đất đai do Văn phòng Quốc hội ban hành” [Consolidated text 44/VBHN-VPQH of 2026 consolidating the Land Law, issued by the Office of the National Assembly], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, July 7, 2026, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bat-dong-san/Van-ban-hop-nhat-44-VBHN-VPQH-2026-Luat-Dat-dai-699655.aspx.
- “Hiến pháp năm 1992” [1992 Constitution], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, October 9, 2023, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bo-may-hanh-chinh/Hien-phap-1992-cong-hoa-xa-hoi-chu-nghia-Viet-nam-38238.aspx.
- “Luật Đất đai 1993” [1993 Land Law], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, January 10, 2025, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bat-dong-san/Luat-Dat-dai-1993-24-L-CTN-38481.aspx.
- “Luật đất đai sửa đổi 1998” [Amended Land Law of 1998], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, January 10, 2025, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bat-dong-san/Luat-dat-dai-1998-sua-doi-10-1998-QH10-44855.aspx.
- “Luật đất đai sửa đổi 2001” [Amended Land Law of 2001], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, January 10, 2025, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bat-dong-san/Luat-dat-dai-2001-sua-doi-25-2001-QH10-47927.aspx.
- Chính phủ Việt Nam [Government of Vietnam], “Nghị định 22/1998/NĐ-CP về đền bù thiệt hại khi Nhà nước thu hồi đất cho mục đích quốc phòng, an ninh, lợi ích quốc gia và công cộng” [Decree 22/1998/NĐ-CP on compensation for damage when the state acquires land for national defense, security, the national interest and public purposes], April 24, 1998, Caselaw.vn, https://caselaw.vn/van-ban-phap-luat/120729-nghi-dinh-so-22-1998-nd-cp-ngay-24-04-1998-cua-chinh-phu-ve-viec-den-bu-thiet-hai-khi-nha-nuoc-nuoc-thu-hoi-de-su-dung-vao-muc-dich-quoc-phong-an-ninh-loi-ich-quoc-gia-loi-ich-cong-cong-van-ban-het-hieu-luc.
- “Luật số 13/2003/QH11 của Quốc hội: Luật đất đai” [Law No. 13/2003/QH11 of the National Assembly: Land Law], Cổng Thông tin điện tử Chính phủ [Government Portal], n.d., http://chinhphu.vn/default.aspx?pageid=27160&docid=32479.
- Trịnh Hữu Long, “Nhà nước pháp quyền qua lăng kính Văn Giang” [The rule-of-law state through the lens of Văn Giang], Blog Trịnh Hữu Long, May 12, 2012, https://blog.trinhhuulong.com/2012/05/12/nha-nuoc-phap-quyen-qua-lang-kinh-van-giang/.
- “Luật đất đai 2013” [2013 Land Law], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, October 7, 2026, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bat-dong-san/Luat-dat-dai-2013-215836.aspx.
- “Luật đất đai 2013.”
- “Văn bản hợp nhất 44/VBHN-VPQH.”
- Hoài Ngân, “Văn Giang, lịch sử một cuộc cưỡng chế” [Văn Giang: The story of a forced land clearance], VnEconomy, May 14, 2012, https://vneconomy.vn/van-giang-lich-su-mot-cuoc-cuong-che.htm.
- Quốc hội [National Assembly], “Nghị quyết 254/2025/QH15 quy định cơ chế, chính sách tháo gỡ khó khăn, vướng mắc trong tổ chức thi hành Luật Đất đai” [Resolution 254/2025/QH15 on mechanisms and policies to resolve difficulties and obstacles in implementing the Land Law], December 11, 2025, Thư Viện Pháp Luật, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bat-dong-san/Nghi-quyet-254-2025-QH15-chinh-sach-thao-go-kho-khan-trong-to-chuc-thi-hanh-Luat-Dat-dai-684580.aspx; see also Chính phủ [Government of Vietnam], Tờ trình số 958/TTr-CP và dự thảo nghị quyết của Quốc hội về tháo gỡ vướng mắc trong thi hành Luật Đất đai [Submission No. 958/TTr-CP and draft National Assembly resolution on resolving obstacles in implementing the Land Law], October 2025, PDF, https://cdn.thuvienphapluat.vn/uploads/tintuc/2025/10/20/2025_10_T%E1%BB%9D%20tr%C3%ACnh%20v%C3%A0%20D%E1%BB%B1%20th%E1%BA%A3o%20Ngh%E1%BB%8B%20quy%E1%BA%BFt%20QH%20th%C3%A1o%20g%E1%BB%A1%20Lu%E1%BA%ADt%20%C4%90%E1%BA%A5t%20%C4%91ai%20-%20958_TTr-CP_compressed.pdf.
- Lê Sáng, “Quốc hội mở rộng thẩm quyền đặc thù cho chủ tịch Hà Nội, cho phép thu hồi đất ngoài Luật Đất đai” [National Assembly expands special powers for Hà Nội’s chairman, allowing land acquisition outside the Land Law], Luật Khoa tạp chí, December 11, 2025, https://luatkhoa.com/2025/12/quoc-hoi-mo-rong-tham-quyen-dac-thu-cho-chu-tich-ha-noi-cho-phep-thu-hoi-dat-ngoai-luat-dat-dai/.
- “Guidance on the Compulsory Purchase Process,” GOV.UK, 2024, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/compulsory-purchase-process-guidance/guidance-on-the-compulsory-purchase-process.
- Francine Sanders Romero, “‘Kelo’ Revisited: 20 Years Since the Controversial Eminent Domain Case,” Planning, May 22, 2025, https://www.planning.org/planning/2025/may/kelo-revisited-20-years-since-the-controversial-eminent-domain-case/.






Join the conversation