When Protests Disguise Themselves Under Other Names

Residents of Lane 467, Residential Group 22, in Vĩnh Hưng Ward march through the streets in matching shirts to protest Sun Group’s project. Photo: Thom Nguyen/Facebook.

These days, a visit to Vĩnh Hưng Ward in Hà Nội reveals groups of people marching through the streets to protest Sun Group’s project. [1] Walking in rows, they wear matching shirts printed with their demands, occasionally raising banners and chanting slogans against the development. [2] On some days, hundreds gather outside the ward People’s Committee headquarters with banners to make their wishes known. [3]

However, when interviewed, the participants firmly refused to say that they were “protesting,” instead calling these activities “strolling the streets,” “exercise walks” or “gathering to petition.” Residents are not the only ones avoiding the term; the police do not use it either, referring to the events as “mass gatherings” and “illegal gatherings and marches.” [4] [5]

Addressing the situation with Luật Khoa, Nguyễn Quang A of the Civil Society Forum said, “That is also a form of opposition, and it can also be called a protest. Compared with the protests of more than 10 years ago, they look quite similar.”

Why has a right written into the Constitution become something that both residents and authorities avoid naming? Furthermore, what happens because of it?

A Fear Rooted in the ‘Anti-State’ Label

In early October, Vĩnh Hưng residents gathered outside the ward People’s Committee to oppose Sun Group’s project. A participating woman was asked whether the crowd was protesting. [6] Before the question was even finished, she waved her hand and said, “We’re just gathering to petition. We’re not protesting to undermine the state.”

This reaction highlights how some residents view protest as something wrong. Notably, she did not only deny participating in a protest; she immediately equated the act with “undermining the state.”

This way of thinking stems from years of authorities and state media associating protests with disorder and riots. [7] The state treats protesting as the seed of resistance to the regime, viewing it as a source of political turmoil that threatens the country’s peace and stability. [8]

As a result, authorities have cracked down on numerous demonstrations over the decades, including the 2011 anti-China protest movement that defended the country’s sovereignty. [9]

Recently, the authorities have intensified efforts to suppress any signs of protest. When residents along the Sông Hồng (Red River) marched in matching shirts to oppose the Red River Scenic Boulevard project, police instructed them to go home and write petitions, claiming that gatherings could disturb security and order. [10]

Similarly, when Vĩnh Hưng residents gathered to oppose Sun Group’s project, the ward police issued a warning that participants would be “dealt with severely.” [11]

In fact, a resident of Lĩnh Nam Ward was fined for “sharing information that incites and entices people to gather in large numbers, affecting security and order.” [12] Others have even faced prison sentences simply for gathering and displaying banners regarding land disputes outside government complaint offices. [13]

Over time, these actions have made many residents wary of protesting, viewing it as a dangerous activity that is easily branded as causing disorder or undermining the state. Addressing this dynamic, Quang A said, “The authorities’ motive is easy to understand: They want to divert public attention. As for the people, it’s probably fear of the authorities.”

What Protest Really Means

In political science, a protest is not necessarily aimed at the government, nor is it synonymous with undermining the state. Rather, it is simply a public, organized activity designed to express opposition to an action or inaction by a government body or organization. [14] Protest takes many forms, ranging from marches, gatherings, and rallies to strikes, boycotts, and petitions.

The U.N. Human Rights Committee’s General Comment No. 37 describes protesting as a way for people to express their views on political and social issues, asserting that this right must be protected. [15] 

In their book,  “A Social Psychology of Protest,” scholars Jacquelien van Stekelenburg and Bert Klandermans treat protest as a form of political participation existing alongside formal institutions. [16]

Furthermore, Article 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)—which Việt Nam is a party to—and Article 25 of Việt Nam’s own Constitution both recognize the right to protest as a legitimate freedom of the people. [17] [18]

Admittedly, the right to protest is not absolute. The state is permitted to set necessary limits to protect security and public order, but authorities are obligated to draw a clear line between peaceful protest and any disorderly acts that may occur. General Comment No. 37 further stresses that the state must not restrict protests to silence opposing political views or government criticism. [19]

This distinction could be clearly observed when participants protesting Sun Group’s project in Vĩnh Hưng continually reminded one another to stand neatly along the roadsides to ensure that they would not block traffic; when they marched, they always walked in orderly rows.

Viewed through this lens, residents protesting a development project or a state land-acquisition decision are not undermining the government. Instead, they are participating in the governing process. They are simply demanding that the state explain decisions directly affecting their lives and adjust those policies to be more lawful, reasonable, and fair.

The Power of the Powerless

According to Quang A, when authorities and residents alike avoid the word “protest,” they are “not calling things by their proper names.” He characterized this as “a very bad habit” that “leads to unforeseeable consequences for society and the country.” In his words: “When the people don’t call things by their proper names, they are unwittingly supporting the rule of dictators!”

This echoes a point he made in an article titled “Việt Nam Should Avoid the Risk of a Mafia Party-State,” where he wrote: “Names that make clear the nature of things are important, because names that don’t can lead to inaccurate, roundabout, and often misleading descriptions.” [20]

This dynamic was discussed by the Czech democracy activist Václav Havel in his 1978 essay “The Power of the Powerless.” Havel argued that telling the truth, and living in truth, is the power of those who have no power. [21]

To illustrate this, Havel tells the story of a greengrocer in Czechoslovakia who displays a propaganda slogan in his shop, even though he does not really believe it. He complies simply because everyone else does, and because he fears the repercussions of refusal.

According to Havel, the rulers sustain a system of power not only through force but also through the compliance of the ruled. By agreeing to display a slogan he does not believe in, the greengrocer unwittingly helps maintain the system. Conversely, when he begins to live by his actual convictions, it becomes a political act.

Viewed through Havel’s lens, the Vĩnh Hưng residents wearing matching shirts and marching with banners are engaging in a similar compromise when they label their opposition an “exercise walk” or “strolling the streets.” While this self-censorship makes them feel safer in the short term, these labels ultimately risk reinforcing the idea that protesting is dangerous and abnormal, despite its recognition as a Constitutional right.

Gradually, a civil right can be pushed out of everyday life. It is not formally erased from the Constitution; rather, it fades because the very people who hold it hesitate to invoke its name.

Residents facing the loss of their homes and land cannot be blamed for choosing language they believe will keep them safe. Their fear is entirely understandable given the vast power gap between citizens and the state.

However, Havel’s philosophy also challenges people to cultivate the courage to speak the truth, enabling them to fully exercise their legal rights. In a society governed by the rule of law, citizens do not need to deny their rights just to prove that they are acting lawfully.


Thực Sơ wrote this article in Vietnamese and published it in Luật Khoa Magazine on Nov. 13, 2026. The Vietnamese Magazine translated it into English.

  1. Thom Nguyen, “Cư dân Ngõ 467 Tổ 22, phường Vĩnh Hưng không …” [Residents of Lane 467, Residential Group 22, Vĩnh Hưng Ward do not …], Facebook, n.d., https://www.facebook.com/thom.nguyen.124479/posts/pfbid02MY9QEoaf6Jf8TBTDuvwj7pH8MNFzWdRvxFbWnL1qPDZkCSND4efbx9UozSobcXRBl.
  2. Post in “Dân cư Dự án Trục đại lộ Cảnh quan Sông Hồng 200.000 hộ dân” [Residents of the Sông Hồng Landscape Boulevard project, 200,000 households], Facebook group, n.d., https://www.facebook.com/groups/2067071373852030/permalink/2210355326190300/.
  3. Lê Sáng, “Phường Vĩnh Hưng: Hàng trăm người tụ tập liên tiếp nhiều ngày, phản đối dự án của Sun Group” [Vĩnh Hưng Ward: Hundreds gather for days in a row to protest Sun Group’s project], Luật Khoa tạp chí, October 11, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/10/phuong-vinh-hung-hang-tram-nguoi-tu-tap-lien-tiep-nhieu-ngay-phan-doi-du-an-cua-sun-group/.
  4. Công an Thành phố Hà Nội [Hà Nội City Police], “Cảnh giác trước các hành vi kích động, lôi kéo tập trung đông người trái pháp luật liên quan đến các dự án trọng điểm của Thủ đô” [Be alert to acts that incite and entice illegal mass gatherings over the capital’s key projects], Cổng Thông tin Điện tử Công an Thành phố Hà Nội, n.d., https://congan.hanoi.gov.vn/tin-tuc/canh-giac-truoc-cac-hanh-vi-kich-dong-39239.
  5. Lê Sáng, “Công an Vĩnh Hưng dọa ‘xử lý nghiêm’ người dân tụ tập, kêu gọi dân ‘tạo điều kiện’ cho Sun Group” [Vĩnh Hưng police threaten to “deal severely” with residents who gather, urge them to “cooperate” with Sun Group], Luật Khoa tạp chí, October 11, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/10/cong-an-vinh-hung-doa-xu-ly-nghiem-nguoi-dan-tu-tap-keu-goi-dan-tao-dieu-kien-cho-sun-group/.
  6. Lê Sáng, “Phường Vĩnh Hưng.”
  7. “Nhận diện nguy cơ ‘cách mạng màu’ và một số vấn đề đặt ra cho an ninh Việt Nam trong bối cảnh hiện nay” [Identifying the risk of a “color revolution” and issues it raises for Việt Nam’s security today], Học viện Chính trị Công an Nhân dân [People’s Police Political Academy], n.d., https://hvctcand.bocongan.gov.vn/nhan-dien-nguy-co-cach-mang-mau-va-mot-so-van-de-dat-ra-cho-an-ninh-viet-nam-trong-boi-canh-hien-nay-8580.
  8. “Nhận diện âm mưu lợi dụng gen Z kích động biểu tình” [Identifying plots to exploit Gen Z to incite protests], ANTV – Truyền hình Công an Nhân dân [People’s Public Security Television], November 20, 2025, https://antv.gov.vn/xa-hoi-4/nhan-dien-am-muu-loi-dung-genz-kich-dong-bieu-tinh-3ACE5DBC0.html.
  9. Trường An, “Nhìn lại phong trào biểu tình chống Trung Quốc sau 15 năm” [Looking back at the anti-China protest movement after 15 years], Luật Khoa tạp chí, June 11, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/06/nhin-lai-phong-trao-bieu-tinh-chong-trung-quoc-sau-15-nam/.
  10. Lê Sáng, “Dự án Sông Hồng: Người dân diễu phố, công an khuyên về viết đơn” [Sông Hồng project: Residents march through the streets; police tell them to go home and write petitions], Luật Khoa tạp chí, June 24, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/06/du-an-song-hong-nguoi-dan-dieu-pho-cong-an-khuyen-ve-viet-don/.
  11. Lê Sáng, “Công an Vĩnh Hưng dọa ‘xử lý nghiêm.’”
  12. Bảo Lâm, “Bị xử phạt 7,5 triệu đồng vì đăng tải thông tin lôi kéo tụ tập đông người tại phường Lĩnh Nam” [Fined 7.5 million đồng for posting information urging people to gather in Lĩnh Nam Ward], Hànộimới, October 30, 2026, https://hanoimoi.vn/bi-xu-phat-7-5-trieu-dong-vi-dang-tai-thong-tin-loi-keo-tu-tap-dong-nguoi-tai-phuong-linh-nam-1763577.html.
  13. Lê Sáng, “Lào Cai: Đi khiếu kiện đất đai, lĩnh án tù 12-18 tháng” [Lào Cai: Land complainants sentenced to 12 to 18 months in prison], Luật Khoa tạp chí, September 25, 2026, https://luatkhoa.com/2026/09/lao-cai-di-khieu-kien-dat-dai-linh-an-tu-12-18-thang/.
  14. “Protester,” National Geographic Education, n.d., https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/protester/.
  15. “The Right of Peaceful Assembly,” OHCHR Regional Office for South-East Asia, 2025, https://bangkok.ohchr.org/article/right-peaceful-assembly.
  16. Jacquelien van Stekelenburg and Bert Klandermans, A Social Psychology of Protest (Cambridge University Press, 2023), 1–16, https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316823354.001.
  17. “Công ước quốc tế về quyền dân sự và chính trị” [International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, November 23, 2020, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Linh-vuc-khac/Cong-uoc-quoc-te-ve-quyen-dan-su-va-chinh-tri-270274.aspx.
  18. “Văn bản hợp nhất 52/VBHN-VPQH năm 2025 hợp nhất Hiến pháp nước Cộng hòa xã hội chủ nghĩa Việt Nam do Văn phòng Quốc hội ban hành” [Consolidated text 52/VBHN-VPQH of 2025 consolidating the Constitution of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam, issued by the Office of the National Assembly], Thư Viện Pháp Luật, August 14, 2025, https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Bo-may-hanh-chinh/Van-ban-hop-nhat-52-VBHN-VPQH-2025-Hien-phap-nuoc-Cong-hoa-xa-hoi-chu-nghia-Viet-Nam-665872.aspx.
  19. “Right of Peaceful Assembly.”
  20. Nguyễn Quang A, “Việt Nam nên tránh nguy cơ đảng–nhà nước mafia” [Việt Nam should avoid the risk of a mafia party-state], Tạp chí Dân Trí, October 2026, https://tapchidantri.org/viet-nam-nen-tranh-nguy-co-dang-nha-nuoc-mafia/.
  21. Václav Havel, The Power of the Powerless (1978), European Parliament, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/100books/en/detail/42/the-power-of-the-powerless.

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Comments are moderated and should be respectful.